Jeff Sadow makes some important observations at the end of one of his recent essays:
‘The larger question about the deployment is its duration. Sure, it can reduce crime, but unless it goes on indefinitely, its benefits will have to be reaped another way that can be implemented while using the Guard as a bridge to achieving that end state. And this is policy action that really must emanate from the local level. Policy made by Landry and/or the Legislature . . . only can go so far.
‘State policy-makers also can address ancillary environmental conditions that can discourage crime, such as reduced government control of economic relations that would encourage opportunity and policies to improve educational attainment, such as greater choice and more rigor in schooling. But as with public safety policy, it will take a similar commitment by local officials to bring about a permanent reduction in crime.
‘Unfortunately, that doesn’t seem forthcoming from a number of such officials. Until that changes – and perhaps this change starts at the voting booth – the benefits of guard deployment for crime reduction will last only as long as the deployment’ (‘Guard Deployment Must Fit Larger Commitment,’ thehayride.com).
The reduction in crime resulting from National Guard deployments won’t last much longer than the deployments themselves. Larger societal changes will be necessary. Mr Sadow mentions improving opportunities for education and economic advancement, but these oft-touted tools of the post-Christian Enlightenment will fail if there is no religious change in the city-dwellers themselves. That is the main ‘environmental condition that can discourage crime’ and get cities on a better path.
Fallen, sinful mankind generally doesn’t want to work too hard to get the money and possessions he desires. He will most often take the path of least resistance. Hence the proliferation of crime. But when the Grace of God touches the souls of fallen men, they will undertake many difficulties for the sake of drawing near to God and serving their neighbors. St Moses the Black is an excellent example of this. He was a notorious criminal but with God’s help he changed completely:
. . .
The rest is at https://thehayride.com/2025/10/garlington-national-guard-deployments-arent-a-long-term-solution-to-big-city-crime/.
--
Holy Ælfred the Great, King of England, South Patron, pray for us sinners at the Souð, unworthy though we are!
Anathema to the Union!